January 2010
AUDIO BOOK REVIEWS
by Jonathan Lowe
History was most cruel for natives of
the Americas after the coming of Christopher
Columbus, as the Spanish invaders plundered
gold in exchange for devastating the populace
with virulent viruses. But what if that
history could be changed? In PASTWATCH
science fiction author Orson Scott Card
postulates the possibility of time travel
to correct the effects begun in 1492 by
sending three travelers back to a time
in the Caribbean before Columbus arrived.
These men are well versed in history,
and know what to say and do in order to
prepare the natives for Columbus, and
to counteract the Catholic church in the
process. The price? The future is forever
and instantly changed to such a degree
that even the scientists who created the
time machines will never have existed.
This paradox leads to a discussion of
causality in which it is explained that
our experience and belief in something
from the past causing what happens in
the future is an illusion, and that causation
is actually a separate thing from time
itself. (Physicists know that there is
no true arrow of time, and that, at least
in theory, the equations work both forward
and backward identically well). So although
the men who created the time machines
will no longer be born after the machines
perform, (and indeed the other two travelers
may cease to exist as well, since the
machines are not perfectly synchronized),
the time traveler will himself survive,
and possess a memory of what will never
happen. This intriguing audiobook is narrated
by Stefan Rudnicki, Scott Brick and others.
Scott, who is a friend of Card, told me
this book is one of his personal favorites.
(Blackstone Audio) |
It's difficult to imagine a better narrator
for NO COUNTRY FOR OLD MEN by Cormac McCarthy
than Sean Barrett, (after hearing this
short novel performed), although (knowing
his work) I'm sure that Tom Stechschulte
is also superb in his version. What makes
Barrett a great choice to speak the killer's
words here is oddly similar to what made
Javier Bardem a great choice for the character
of Anton Chigurh in the Coen brothers
movie version. Barrett has an understated,
calm, but not quite laid-back air about
his delivery, with vocal characteristics
to match. There's an element of tension
present that the mirror surface can't
quite hide. You expect the worst to happen,
and it does. As for the story, if you're
unfamiliar with it, it's about an escaped
killer tracking a man who found a bag
of money related to a failed drug buy.
Tommy Lee Jones plays the sheriff in the
movie, and he's trying to find both men
before they find each other. Sounds simple
enough. But as this morality tale plays
out against the stark backdrop of west
Texas it also expands its reach past mere
entertainment into the realm of literature
by extending its scope beyond three men
in the desert to the bigger questions
that have plagued man from the beginning.
Hearing this "audio movie" version will
be instructive for Coen brothers fans
and screenwriters too, since you can compare,
as I did, the dialogue between the book
and the movie, and so see what choices
the Coen brothers made in editing. Surprisingly,
they stayed pretty much with the story,
(except for one major scene), and were
true to the dialogue too, but there are
other subtle differences. (Some scenes
were tightened, others emphasized by the
Coens. Little extra dialogue was added,
but some was subtracted.) By comparing,
you will be able to figure out why (and
which) things work better on the screen
or on the page. As reader, Sean Barrett
is an appropriate guide to this very original
story, with spot-on west Texas accents
and believable female characters, too.
Speaking in the voice of the killer, though,
he's chillingly real and a minimalist
just like Chigurh himself—a man
of few emotions, attuned to destiny, accepting
of fate, just telling it like it is, whether
you like what truths are revealed about
the world or not. (Naxos) |
In Lauren Grodstein's latest family-centered
tear jerker A FRIEND OF THE FAMILY, credibility
is added by what might seem to be narrator
Rick Adamson's emotional empathy with
the character of the doctor, whose distrust
of his best friend's daughter escalates
when the girl shows up in her 30s to seduce
his son. The son is attempting to establish
a career as an artist, utilizing his father's
garage, but this older woman in his life
wants to take him to France after showing
him the ropes of romance. Soap opera fans
will especially enjoy the depths and sensitivity
of the story, which contains much less
melodrama and much more realism than anything
on television, while keeping the level
of tension high. Those looking for two
dimensional characters involved in fantastical
plots, on the other hand, might want to
stay away. There is plenty of argument
going on here, and cross accusations.
The interesting aspect of the audiobook
is how much risk Adamson takes in pushing
the envelope, especially toward the end.
This is superb acting on the level of
off-Broadway performance, doubly notable
due to the restrained contrast evoked
in other character voices, which turn
on a dime. Once again, you have to ask
yourself, can typical screen actors do
this? One may never know, since they aren't
required to do it. (Highbridge) |
Finally, Alan Sklar reads MIAMI BABYLON
by Gerald Posner, a book that chronicles
the history of Miami Beach from its fledgling
Prohibition days through the corrupt machinations
of its sordid developer fights and payoffs
in the 90s. Since the need for tourism
clashed with the wills of permanent residents,
clubs like Amnesia fought noise ordinances
with high priced lawyers while distributing
Estasy and belting out thunderous rap
music through the surrounding concrete
condo towers. In the TV show CSI Miami,
like in the cop show Miami Vice,
you remember those towers and art deco
clubs, which whispered by in the night,
but you never saw the bigger battles which
became public as massive egos in both
City Hall and developers' drawing rooms
vied for victory, using zoning laws and
high rise buildings like pieces on a chess
board. That story is here, well told by
Posner and Sklar, along with the amoral
jet set crowd which frequented the raucous
clubs at a time when Madonna penned her
book SEX, and when you might be pepper-sprayed
for trying to get into a club she'd just
entered. From coke dealers and playboys
to back room real-estate-mogul power plays,
the book is a treasure trove of information
on how corruption unfolds in a city's
grab for gold. As for Miami, it's a roller
coaster ride between boom and bust, and
the audiobook a cautionary but true tale
about government, race relations, and
the inevitability of kickbacks. (Tantor
Media) (For interviews with audiobook
narrators, visit Jonathan's blog at
AudiobooksToday.Blogspot.com) |
|