Another Review at MyShelf.Com

Inside the Magic, Keyholders 3

by Debbie Dadley and Marcia Thornton Jones
Illustrated by Adam Stower

     

In this third entry in the Keyholder series, the three young keyholders are facing a terrible problem. Their mentor, Mr. Leery, has been kidnapped by the Queen of the Boggarts. The keyholders have to enter the magical realm and brave all sorts of dangers to get him back. As with the other two books in the series, the plot is simple and straightforward. The young characters must learn to work together to accomplish the task and these three don't work together well. The quest nature of this plot kept reader attention well, and the line illustrations by Adam Stower really helped make the children and creatures feel more real. I'm still not completely certain I like these three children. Luke's self-absorbed ego and Natalie's foolish bravado are much alike and push the characters into much of their trouble, and sometimes it's hard to be completely convinced they deserve to get out of it, with their squabbling and whining. I must admit, it's a gutsy choice to flout the "writing rule" to make your main character likeable, and one that may ultimately pay off for the series. Certainly Dadley and Jones have the experience to know what their readers enjoy. The fantasy creatures are interesting and always surprising with their very human traits and character weaknesses as well. For a young chapter book lover with a taste for fantasy, the magic and the quest are sure to take the reader on an engaging journey.

The Book

Starscape / Tom Doherty Associates
November 2009
Mass Market Paperback
9780765359841 / 0765359847
Fantasy Ages 7-9
More at Amazon.com
Excerpt
NOTE:

The Reviewer

Jan Fields
Reviewed 2009
NOTE: Reviewer Jan Fields is the editor of Kid Magazine Writers emagazine and has written dozens of stories and articles for the children's magazine market.
© 2009 MyShelf.com