Another Review at MyShelf.Com

The Black Isle
Sandi Tan

Hachette Audio
August 7, 2012/ ASIN: B008U2PAUU
General Fiction / China/ Audiobook - 21 hours, 38 minutes
Amazon

Reviewed by Jo Rogers


The Black Isle is the story of a young Chinese girl from Shanghai. It is told in flashback form, beginning and ending with Ling as an old woman. The memories begin when Ling and her twin brother, Li, are celebrating their seventh birthday. According to their mother, when Ling was born first, she was a healthy baby. When Li arrived five minutes later, he was thin and malnourished. Their mother claimed that Ling was greedy during their gestation and took more than her fair share of the nourishment. They were born in 1922.

On that day, Li asked his mother to take them to the park. Their mother was agoraphobic, and shouted a resounding “No” to a son she denied nothing. She relented later and let one of the two nannies take them out. While they were there, they encountered an older gentleman who wanted to show them something. It was a tiny kitten with three broken legs. It belonged to the gentleman, and he wanted them to break the kitten’s neck, which Li did. From then on, Li suffered from anemia and Ling began to see and hear ghosts.

The Black Isle is a captivating story of growing up in China in the era preceding World War II and surviving Japanese occupation. It is the story of rebuilding shattered lives after the war only to see them destroyed by the very ones who rebuilt them in the first place. It is the story of growing old alone and bitter. It is beautifully written. The characters are fully developed and totally human. The plot is simple and takes some unusual turns with the ghosts. Though the story is long, reader Sarah Zimmerman makes it well worth the time spent listening. So, listen to The Black Isle and take a journey to another time and place.

Reviewer's Note: Contains sex, violence, profanity
Reviewed 2012
© MyShelf.com