The housekeeper of a wealthy family on the island is found dead. She's hidden the recently stolen rare Double Eagle coins in Annie and Max's home. The victim's church chooses to keep the secrets of the dead - until someone steps forward anonymously and puts Annie in the public eye as well as in danger.

It's Annie's luck to have the romantic setting of her historical home initiated with mystery and mayhem. And it's Carolyn Hart's talent that gives readers likable characters, natural dialogue, a multifaceted mystery and a charming island backdrop - even if it is out of season and a bit chilly this time around. Fans will enjoy the role of armchair detective with Max and Annie, as well as seeing the characters move forward in their lives. In this episode, the popular bookstore is a secondary backdrop to the new historical home and surrounding area. But fear not, the Mystery Painting contest goes on.