If, like me, you miss the days when cozy mysteries were more about low violence than marketing
opportunities involving special hobbies and recipes inside, may I introduce you to Sheila Simonson.
Her writing isn't remotely cutesy, as even some old-fashioned cozies could be, which is why I call
her type of stories traditional—low violence stories based on good storytelling and good
writing (very good in her case with both), usually with a small town setting, and with
relationships and understanding of people at their core.
An Old Chaos is the second in her LaTouche County mystery series set in the Pacific
Northwest. Like the first book, this is a beautifully literate read that draws you in until you're
buried in its flow without realizing it. When I say literate, I don't mean that it tries to impress
you with big words or obscure quotations, although heroine Meg McLean is a librarian. I mean that
the prose is beautifully crafted and evocative, telling the story smoothly but effectively, making
for very easy but richly enjoyable reading.
A landslide buries a newish development of expensive houses, killing six people. This would be
one thing if it had simply been an unpreventable act of god, but just before the landslide, word
had started to leak about warnings against building there that had been suppressed. Obviously
corruption was involved, but exactly who got paid off, how and why, and by whom?
Meg and Sheriff's Investigator Rob Neill are the central investigators in a story about past
corruption and new crimes to maintain the cover-up, but part of the fun is that the story isn't
told wholly from their viewpoint. You see how events affect Rob's cousin, come to visit at the
wrong time, Madeline Thomas, principal chief of the Klalos Indians and a person of considerable
local power, a "girls just want to have fun" efficient young nurse forced to face a lot more than
going home with a loser, and more. I'm not usually a fan of that sort of round robin viewpoint,
but it's very well integrated here and really makes for a much more interesting story, in large
part because the characterization is so well done.
Highly recommended for a lose yourself in it story about believably real people you care deeply
about in a believably real setting, dealing with unimaginable but all too believable events.