A Joe Sandilands Murder Mystery - Book
VIII
Barbara Cleverly
Constable (Constable and
Robinson)
3 November 2011 / ISBN: 9781849019965
Historical Mystery / 1922 /London
Amazon
US
- UK
Reviewed
by Rachel A Hyde
When two gunmen murder
Admiral Lord Dedhan outside his home, it looks as though the Fenians
are at it again. Commander Joe Sandilands has recently returned
from India and impresses everybody at Scotland Yard with his mixture
of diplomacy and derring-do. WPC Lily Wentworth also has talent
and ability, but cuts dictate that she is going to get made redundant;
not being upper class is not in her favor. But Joe has seen her
in action and is impressed, so it looks as though she will be hanging
onto her job for a while longer. Not only that, but Cinderella is
about to go to the ball with a real prince
Habitual visitors to this site will know that Ms Cleverly is one
of my favorite historical mystery writers. Her mix of classic whodunit,
exotic locations, exciting action and surprising plot twists make
for very enjoyable reading. This book takes us back in time four
years from the end of the last book, when Joe was newly arrived
in England and all set for a starry career as a Scotland Yard hero.
Usually he takes center stage, but this time that role belongs more
to his new sidekick, Lily. What follows is a Cinderella story that
at times feels more suitable for a romance, although this is in
no way a romantic book. Joe is seen in this book as an impressive
but often distant figure, a mixture of war hero, diplomat extraordinaire
and aristocratic adventurer. Lily is a girl from an ordinary background
but with more than ordinary talent who is suddenly propelled into
the limelight.
All this would have
been better if the story was not so very long, with rather more
talk about action than action itself. This has the effect of slowing
down the story so that it loses too much momentum and is often hard
to engage with. I imagine that such a talented author as Ms Cleverly
is trying out a slight twist on her usual style as she did in Bright
Hair About The Bone (also reviewed on this site) so I conclude that
it will be interesting to see what she does next.
|