Another Review at MyShelf.Com

Unnatural Habits
Phryne Fisher #19
Kerry Greenwood

Poisoned Pen Press
2013/ ISBN 9781464201257
Mystery / Historical/ Australia / 1920s

Reviewed by LJ Roberts

 

First Sentence: The attack came on suddenly.

Young pregnant girls are going missing and reporter Polly Kettle thinks she knows what is happening to them. Then Polly disappears. Phryne and her minions are on a case that involves much more than first thought.

Greenwood has the most wonderful voice and use of humor…”This was going to be an evening where she needed every single whit about her, as plate armour was no longer worn in polite society.” At the same time, the book addresses several serious social issues, but in a way that’s never preachy. “Unnatural Habits” looks at the Magdelene Laundries run by the Catholic Church using single, pregnant young women; sex trafficking and the gay community in the 20s.

Phryne Fisher is one of the most wonderful protagonists one can find. She comes from poor beginnings and has never forgotten them, but has gained wealth. She is independent, strong and very capable yet, through the series, “adopts” people into her informal family. She believes in manners and elegance, yet stands up for those who are abused, oppressed or discriminated against and is intolerant of cruelty. In a “gentleman only” club where Phryne is invited to join them for lunch, she is told she will be an honorary gentleman, to which she responds, “I have always tried to behave as one.” At the same time, she is not above the appropriately used insult, invective or expletive.

Greenwood’s descriptions place one in Phryne’s world. The descriptions of food are mouth-watering and of clothes leaving us to wish for a more elegant time. At the same time, Greenwood expects a level of intelligence from her readers. Aside from being a fun detective story, it is—as are all the books in the series—a book with a strong social conscience.

Although Phryne’s involvement in solving crimes with the approval of the police may be improbable, one doesn’t really care. All the threads are neatly tied, all the questions satisfactorily answered, and justice, either legally or morally, is served.

Unnatural Habits is a totally, delightfully fun read with a very good twist.

Reviews of other titles in this series

Cocaine Blues #1
Flying Too High #2
Murder on the Ballarat Train #3
Death at Victoria Dock #4
The Green Mill Murder #5
Blood and Circuses #6
Ruddy Gore #7
Urn Burial #8
Raisins and Almonds #9
Death Before Wicket #10
Murder in Montparnasse #12
Murder in the Dark #16
Murder on a Midsummer Night #17
Unnatural Habits #19




Reviewed 2015
© MyShelf.com