Another Review at MyShelf.Com

Associates of Sherlock Holmes
Edited by George Mann

Titan Books
23 August 2016/ ISBN 9781783299300
Mystery/Historical

Reviewed by Rachel A Hyde

 

The game is afoot, but not just for Holmes and Watson in this compilation of stories featuring other characters from the canon. Read about cases from the viewpoint of various detectives, clients, associates and even villains in thirteen new short stories.

I had hoped for one from Moriarty’s viewpoint, but this is surprisingly absent. Instead the main villain featured is Colonel Moran, but other choices include Irene Adler, Lestrade, Mycroft, more than one Irregular, various police and detectives plus clients like Violet Hunter (Copper Beeches) and Helen Stoner (Speckled Band). Some are characters we know a lot about, others are merely names and the authors have spun a background as well as a story for them. Some follow on from existing stories directly, so knowledge of the originals is a good idea. Each tale has a short introduction describing the person chosen as the protagonist and why they were selected in the words of the author. Most of the stories involve flesh and blood crimes but a few venture into the supernatural; Moran hunts a fearsome quarry in the backwoods of the Pacific Northwest, Helen Stoner makes some unusual discoveries about her stepfather’s menagerie and hapless “Creeping Man” Professor Presbury has another encounter with more of the same. As with any set of short stories everybody will differ on their own personal favorites but I was impressed with Ian Edginson’s tale of the misadventures of a professor and his Anglo Saxon “treasure” as it had such a plausible explanation. I also enjoyed reading about Irene Adler’s forays into the world of Parisian nightlife (Cavan Scott), which had a neat twist and she is always worth reading about, a strong woman fighting to stay on top in a man’s world. Then there was Sebastian Moran’s hunting trip which made a change from foggy London, wasn’t a crime story and was brilliantly narrated in exactly the right amoral tone by Tim Pratt. An imaginative collection of tales that ought to have a sequel as there are so many more viewpoints to tell stories from.

Reviewers Note: Some gory scenes

Reviewed 2016
© MyShelf.com