Luckily what Meg lacks in looks she makes up for in intelligence. While Wat goes off with his men fighting against the English, she takes over his home and adds a woman’s touch, much to his disgust. In fact, Wat seems unable to appreciate much about Meg; he verbally abuses her, threatens her physically, and behaves selfishly in bed. Although he’s the one with the power, money, and good looks, sometimes it seems like she got the worst end of the deal.

The author spends a considerable amount of time describing the political intrigue surrounding the border dispute, and sometimes the story feels bogged down by the history. Although the two characters (and some secondary characters) make interesting subjects, the romantic elements are downplayed by the near-constant talk of politics and war to such an extent that it’s hard to see when or why Wat and Meg ever fall in love. Based on real and legendary characters from Scotland’s past, history buffs will appreciate this book more than hopeless romantics.