For over thirty years, Robert B. Parker has produced adult novels that have made him one of the godfathers of modern
day mysteries. His dry wit, crackling dialogue and iconic characters have produced many a bestseller. Last year, he
produced his first YA novel,
Edenville Owls, and now he’s written his second book for young adults, The Boxer and The Spy.
And the results are a mixed bag.
A young teenager is found dead on a beach in a small town north of Boston. The boy’s death is ruled a suicide,
but Terry Novak, a fifteen year old classmate and wanna-be boxer, doesn’t believe that. Terry and his small group
of friends begin to investigate and quickly realize that things don’t add up. Terry is a very likable hero and
seems very much to be a younger version of Parker’s iconic private detective hero, Spenser - earnest, intelligent,
funny. His desire to learn the truth seems very genuine. Terry’s relationship with his girlfriend, Abby, is quite
charming, as is his bond with his mentor and boxing trainer, George.
But the things that work so well in Parker’s adult novels don’t work quite as well here. The plot is a bit too
simple and the villains are thinly veiled. The teenager characters seem more suited for the 1950’s than the supposed
contemporary setting of the novel, their dialogue - always the best part of Parker’s adult novels - a bit awkward
and out of date. In theory, Terry’s investigation puts both him and his pals in danger, but that threat never
feels fully realized.
Even with those flaws, however, readers will probably stick with the novel to discover the ending, which ties up
the story nicely. Sophisticated young mystery readers may find this one too easy, but The Boxer and The Spy
should have some appeal for teens who are just getting a feel for mysteries.